Dalam debat saya dengan Montje, saya berargumen bahwa sejak di Mekkah sebenarnya Muhammad telah merancangkan kecelakaan atas bangsanya sendiri, Quraish.
Gebyar imperialisme Muhammad yang diawali dengan 13 tahun di Mekkah "tanpa darah" memang lebih dipopulerkan sebagai misi "damai" walaupun sebenarnya tidak demikian. Selama 13 tahun itu Muhammad terus menerus mencela pengikut agama leluhurnya sendiri sebagai pelaku "dosa besar" [Quran 56:46] dan "sampah yang akan dibuang ke dalam "angin yang amat panas dan air panas yang mendidih" [Quran 56:41-42]. Muhammad bahkan menuduh dan mengancam kaum penyembah berhala Mekah dengan berkata, "Demikianlah Kami berbuat terhadap orang-orang yang berdosa. Kecelakaan yang besarlah pada hari itu bagi orang-orang yang mendustakan." [Quran 77:18-19]. Muhammad menyebut dirinya dan pengikutnya sebagai "orang-orang benar" dan mereka yang menolaknya disebutnya sebagai "penipu", "pelaku kejahatan", dan "pencipta kebohongan". [Quran 90:17-20], [Quran 16:104-105]
Jihad dengan kata-kata rupa-rupanya tidak membuahkan kemualafan kaum Quraish Mekkah. Untuk itu Muhammad harus merubah strategi imperialismenya dengan pedang. Hal ini tidak mungkin dilakukan saat itu di Mekkah karena kekuatannya yang masih sangat lemah. Dia harus hijrah ke Medinah, menyusun kekuatan untuk membuat perhitungan dengan Quraish Mekkah.
Jalan satu-satunya yang bisa dilakukan untuk membenarkan serangannya nanti adalah dengan membuat cerita bahwa dia diserang terlebih dahulu oleh penduduk Mekkah sehingga dia harus "melarikan diri" ke Medinah.
Bagian pertama yang ingin saya buktikan adalah: TUDUHAN BAHWA KAUM QURAISH BERUSAHA MEMBUNUH MUHAMMAD TERLEBIH DAHULU adalah OMONG KOSONG!
Saya menantang muslims untuk membuktikan bahwa Muhammad diserang terlebih dahulu.
Sdr. Montje memberi "bukti":
Tanggapan saya:Head Fixer wrote: Ibnu Kathir menjelaskan ayat berikut sebab2 turunnya ...
QS 22 : 39 :
Telah diizinkan (berperang) bagi orang-orang yang diperangi, karena sesungguhnya mereka telah dianiaya. 1) Dan sesungguhnya Allah, benar-benar Maha Kuasa menolong mereka itu,
Tafsir Ibnu Kathir AlHajj [22 : 39]
Allah prescribed Jihad at an appropriate time 2), because when they were in Makkah, the idolators outnumbered them by more than ten to one. Were they to engage in fighting at that time, the results would have been disastrous. When the idolators went to extremes to persecute Muslims, to expel the Prophet and resolving to kill him; when they sent his Companions into exile here and there, so that some went to Ethiopia and others went to Al-Madinah; when they settled in Al-Madinah and the Messenger of Allah joined them there, and they gathered around him and lent him their support, and they had a place where Islam prevailed, and a stronghold to which they could retreat; then Allah prescribed Jihad against the enemy, and this was the first Ayah to be revealed for it. Allah said:
(Permission (to fight) is given to those fought against, because they have been wronged; and surely, Allah is able to give them victory. Those who have been expelled from their homes unjustly)
Al-`Awfi reported that Ibn `Abbas said; "They were driven out of Makkah to Al-Madinah unjustly, i.e., Muhammad and his Companions.''
Ibnu Ishaq juga melaporkan kejadian percobaan pembunuhan ini .... yg menyebabkan nabi pergi secara diam2 ke madina bersama Abu Bakar dan sbgmana kita ketahui ayat ttg perang saat itu belum turun.
According to Ibn Ishaq : 3)
"When they all began to discuss the problem of Muhammad, one of them said :
1. ‘Put him in irons, imprison him, and wait till he dies as has happened to other poets before him.’
Then the sheikh exclaimed, ‘No, by Allah! If you incarcerate him as you propose, the news will leak out to his companions and they will undoubtedly attack you and liberate him. Then, through his agency they will so increase in number as to conquer you. This is not the thing to do; you must devise another plan !’ They consulted further, and another man said,
2. We shall expel him from our midst, and exile him from our country. After he departs, we care not where he goes nor what happens to him as long as we can arrange our affairs and re‑establish peace amongst us.’
ikh said again, ‘No, by Allah! Do you not realize that by his fine conversation, his sweetness of speech, and his power over the hearts of men, he could conquer any Arab encampment in which he might settle; then the people would follow him, march against you, and deprive you of your supremacy. After that he could deal with you just as he liked. Therefore think of another plan.’
Abu Jahl at last exclaimed, ‘By Allah I I have a plan which none of you has yet thought of’, and they asked, ‘What is it, o father of wisdom?’ He said,
3. ‘I propose that from every tribe we should take one young, powerful, well‑born man. To each of these, we should give a good sword with which to strike Muhammad. So we shall be delivered of him, his blood will be divided among all the tribes, and his followers will not have the strength to make war on so many.’
The sheikh said, ‘I see no other plan and the people adopted the proposal and then dispersed."
http://www.faithfreedom.org/Articles/sira/07.htm" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
1) "Bukti" bahwa Muhammad diserang terlebih dahulu oleh Quraish Mekkah adalah OMONGAN AUWLOH (kentara sekali bikinan Muhammadnya) bahwa mereka dianiaya (tapi tetap segar-bugar
). Masuk akal ga? 
2) Allah prescribed Jihad at an appropriate time
Sebelum ada serangan apa-apa atas diri Muhammad, ALLAH TELAH MERACIK, MEMPERSIAPKAN, MENETAPKAN, MENYURUH Jihad pada waktu yang ditetapkan. Yang nentukan timing jihadnya syafa? Justru bukti ini membuktikan bahwa saat itu Muhammad sudah punya konsep jihad yang masih dalam bentuk kepongpong!
3) Saya tidak tau siapa yang membuat cerita ini, tetapi "kongkow2" alias ngobrol2nya orang Quraisy untuk "membunuh" Muhammad diartikan demikian serius oleh muslims sebagai "bukti" serangan atas diri Muhammad terlebih dahulu.
4) "Bukti" bahwa nyawa Muhammad terancam adalah dengan "towelan" malaikat Gabriel yang membangunkan Muhammad pada malam hari itu juga agar cabut dari Mekkah. Montje mengaku sendiri seperti kisah Yesus, tetapi peristiwa yang dia kutib salah (baca Alkitab lebih banyak lagi, Mont!). Yang benar adalah: Kisah literaturnya nyontek ayat ini: Matius 2:13-14 "... nampaklah malaikat Tuhan kepada Yusuf dalam mimpi dan berkata: 'Bangunlah, ambillah Anak itu serta ibu-Nya, larilah ke Mesir dan tinggallah di sana sampai Aku berfirman kepadamu, karena Herodes akan mencari Anak itu untuk membunuh Dia'. Maka Yusufpun bangunlah, diambilnya Anak itu serta ibu-Nya malam itu juga, lalu menyingkir ke Mesir".Head Fixer wrote:ini kapir kebanyakan baca artikel2 tendensius jadi kasian gue ...baca terusan sirah nya .... supaya luh ngerti seberapa serius KONGKOW2 itu ... aaah parah luh pir ... mereka bener2 merealisasikan kongkownya. hanya saja Nabi saw berhasil lolos dari maut dgn mukjizat spt yesus yg menghilang di bait Allah.. 4) ngarti pir ??
Abu Jahl at last exclaimed, ‘By Allah I I have a plan which none of you has yet thought of’, and they asked, ‘What is it, o father of wisdom?’ He said, ‘I propose that from every tribe we should take one young, powerful, well‑born man. To each of these, we should give a good sword with which to strike Muhammad. So we shall be delivered of him, his blood will be divided among all the tribes, and his followers will not have the strength to make war on so many.’ The sheikh said, ‘I see no other plan and the people adopted the proposal and then dispersed.
But Gabriel came to the apostle of Allah and said to him, ‘Do not spend this night in thy accustomed bed.’
When a part of the night had elapsed the conspirators assembled at Muhammad’s door to watch him, intending to fall upon lie he was asleep. When the apostle of Allah saw them he said to Ali, ‘Sleep on my bed and cover thyself with my green cloak, and they will do thee no harm.’ It was the custom of the apostle to sleep in that cloak. Meanwhile Abu Jah1jeeringly told the waiting conspirators, ‘Muhammad says that if you follow him you will become princes both of the Arabs and the non-Arabs, that you will be resurrected after death, and given gardens like the gardens of Jordan; but if you do not follow him, he will kill you and after death you will be resurrected and burn in the fires of hell.’
The apostle went out to them and said, ‘Yes! That is thc truth’, and Allah blinded them so that they could not see him. Then Muhammad scattered dust on their heads, recited a verse from the Koran, and went about his business.
After a while, a man came along and asked the still waiting conspirators, ‘What are you waiting for?’ and they replied, ‘Muhammad.’ ‘May Allah confound you!’ the man exclaimed. ‘Muhammad came out to you, and scattered dust on the head of every man among you, and then went his way. Can you not see what has happened to you?’ Every man placed his hand on his head, and found that dust was on it, and then they began to search around. Finding Ali on the bed, wrapped in the cloak of the apostle, they said, ‘Here is Muhammad still sleeping in his mantle!’ ‑ and so they did not move until morning. But it was Ali who rose from the bed, and they realized that the man who had spoken to them had told the truth.
Bualan Muhammad yang jelas-jelas nyontek literatur kristen!
Ayo Mon, sodorkan versi islamnya, Muhammad bersembunyi di gua Hira, lalu datang laba2 membuat jaring, kemudian bala tentara Quraish lewat dan tidak menemukan apa-apa, bla.... bla....bla...
Ayo muslim-muslim yang lain, bantu uztadmu untuk memberikan BUKTI yang lebih masuk akal lagi.
BTW, aq senang dengan istilah yang kau pakai "tendensius". Kita buktikan saja siapa yang tendensius, aku apa Muhammad!